Rob FrascaAll ideas

Five Stages of Disintermediation.

Intermediaries are not obsolete in principle. They become obsolete in arithmetic.

FrameworkaCommerceCapitalPlatform shifts

The End of Trust Intermediaries

For most of history, every trust question had the same answer: an intermediary. A bank vouched that you had the money. A broker vouched for the trade. A registrar vouched that you owned the property. A platform vouched that the seller was real. They stood in the middle, they charged for standing there, and over time they captured a large share of the value that moved through them.

Thomas Philippon’s research puts a number on that toll. Studying 130 years of U.S. finance, he found the annual cost of intermediation at roughly two percent of outstanding assets, and found that it rose over the last thirty years instead of falling. Trust is what that margin buys. When trust becomes provable and portable, the margin faces competition for the first time.

TOLL EVERY TRIPATTEST ONCEPROOF TRAVELSAGENTMERCHANT
From a toll on every trip to a passport issued once.

Intermediaries are not obsolete in principle. They become obsolete in arithmetic. I expect the shift to arrive in five stages. Identity and proof are the foundation for every stage after the first.

Template contracts
Observable today. Standard agreements executed by software.
Composed contracts
Emerging. Agents assemble agreements from verified parts.
Adaptive contracts
Projected. Terms that adjust to verified conditions.
Emergent instruments
Projected. New financial forms that only machines can coordinate.
Dissolution
Projected. The middle layer becomes infrastructure.
From the book
The intermediary that once collected a toll on every trip becomes the one that issues the passport.
Rob FrascaThe Creator’s Journey (forthcoming)
From the research
What is needed is an electronic payment system based on cryptographic proof instead of trust, allowing any two willing parties to transact directly with each other without the need for a trusted third party.
Satoshi NakamotoBitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, 2008

The job changes. The toll booth closes.

Does this mean the end of banks, brokers and platforms? No. Someone still has to vouch for the facts a proof is built on. Before a proof can show you are an accredited investor, a trusted party has to check that you are and attest to it. In trusted agent commerce, the attestation happens once, and the proof travels on its own.

That changes how much rent an intermediary can extract. Much less. It is probably not a good time to be a bank that plans to keep doing business the way it does today. It is a very good time to be an institution that understands its future job is attestation, not toll collection.

Run an intermediary audit

  1. List who vouches for youWrite every intermediary your business depends on for identity, payment, ownership or reputation.
  2. Ask which trust could become a proofFor each one, ask whether a verifiable proof could replace the check made on every transaction.
  3. Place each on the five stagesMark whether that relationship is observable, emerging or still projected.
  4. If you are the intermediary, choose your jobAttestation or toll collection. Plan for the first.

Quick answers

What is disintermediation in agent commerce?

Rob Frasca describes trust moving from human intermediaries to systems that can prove what they claim. Intermediaries keep a role, but it shifts from collecting a toll on every transaction to issuing an attestation once.

Will AI agents replace banks?

Rob Frasca’s view is no. Society still needs trusted parties to verify identity and attest to facts. The institutions at risk are the ones that plan to keep earning by standing in the middle of every transaction.

Sources

  1. Rob Frasca, The Creator’s Journey (forthcoming), Chapter XIV, When Agents Act.
  2. Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, 2008. Source
  3. Thomas Philippon, “Has the US Finance Industry Become Less Efficient? On the Theory and Measurement of Financial Intermediation,” NBER Working Paper 18077, 2012; American Economic Review, 2015. Source
Open the interactive version