Rob FrascaAll ideas

Intelligence Layer, Settlement Layer.

AI is the intelligence layer. Blockchain is the settlement layer.

EssayAICapital

The End of Trust Intermediaries

Much of finance exists to manufacture trust between parties who cannot verify each other. Brokers, agents, clearing layers. Each one adds cost and delay. For most of history that was the only way. Someone had to stand in the middle and vouch.

Platform shifts stack. The internet made data abundant. AI makes that data useful. New settlement systems make it possible to act on it with trust. The creator who understands the stack can see where the next piece is missing.

From the book
I think of AI as the intelligence layer and blockchain as a settlement layer: one helps decide what should happen, the other records that it did.
Rob FrascaThe Creator’s Journey (forthcoming)
From the research
For an exchange to be executed, key attributes of a transaction need to be verified by the parties involved at multiple points in time.
Christian Catalini and Joshua S. GansSome Simple Economics of the Blockchain, 2020
INTELLIGENCEDECIDES WHAT SHOULD HAPPENSETTLEMENTRECORDS THAT IT DIDAILEDGER
One layer decides. The other proves it happened.

Two layers, two jobs

Intelligence layer
AI. It searches, compares, reasons and decides what should happen. On its own, it can make an honest mistake at machine speed, and nobody can easily check whom it acts for.
Settlement layer
A ledger. It records that something happened, with finality anyone can verify. On its own, it decides nothing.

Each layer covers the other’s gap. An agent that can decide but cannot prove who it acts for gets refused at the door. A ledger that can prove but cannot decide just waits. Put them together with regulated infrastructure and programmable assets, and many of the middle layers lose their reason to exist.

Why the economics point the same way

Christian Catalini of MIT and Joshua Gans of the University of Toronto made the case in Some Simple Economics of the Blockchain. They named two costs a ledger can lower: the cost of verification and the cost of networking. Every exchange needs its key facts checked, and today intermediaries charge to check them. When verification becomes cheap, marketplaces can form without traditional trusted intermediaries. That is the economic core of The End of Trust Intermediaries, the book Dr. Zdenka Cumano and I are writing.

The first place the stack is being tested is agent commerce. Agents will need verified identities and wallets to transact with each other. That is a settlement problem and an identity problem. It is the next infrastructure phase.

Map your own stack

  1. List the decisionsWrite down the decisions in your business that software could make or prepare. That is your intelligence layer.
  2. List the recordsWrite down what must be proven afterward: payment, ownership, identity, compliance. That is your settlement layer.
  3. Find the middlemenMark every party that exists mainly to verify one of those records. Note what each costs in fees and days.
  4. Ask which check could become a proofFor each one, ask whether a verifiable record could replace the check that is repeated on every transaction.

Quick answers

What is the difference between the intelligence layer and the settlement layer?

In Rob Frasca’s framing, AI is the intelligence layer: it helps decide what should happen. Blockchain is the settlement layer: it records that it did, in a way anyone can verify. Together they can replace much of the trust that intermediaries now sell.

What is The End of Trust Intermediaries about?

It is a book in development by Rob Frasca and Dr. Zdenka Cumano. It argues that much of finance exists to manufacture trust between parties who cannot verify each other, and that AI combined with verifiable settlement and regulated infrastructure makes that trust provable.

Sources

  1. Rob Frasca, The Creator’s Journey (forthcoming), Chapter VI, Seeing the Shift, and Chapter XIV, When Agents Act.
  2. Rob Frasca and Dr. Zdenka Cumano, The End of Trust Intermediaries (book in development).
  3. Christian Catalini and Joshua S. Gans, “Some Simple Economics of the Blockchain,” Communications of the ACM 63, no. 7 (2020): 80 to 90. Source
Open the interactive version