The Impact-Innovation Loop.
A clear mission sharpens what you see. What you see produces better questions. Better questions produce innovations that matter.
The Creator's Journey · Chapter II, The Creator's Mind
Over three decades of building, I began to notice a pattern. Founders deeply connected to an impact mission innovated differently from founders chasing a market opportunity. Both groups worked hard. Both were smart. But they found different answers, and the difference showed up again and again. I call it the Impact-Innovation Loop.
- Mission sharpens observationIf you are committed to changing how people access information, you notice friction others step over: the person who cannot get an answer, the process that wastes a day, the gatekeeper nobody questions.
- Visible problems produce better questionsA founder chasing a market asks what people will pay for. A founder serving an impact asks what would have to change for this problem to disappear.
- Better questions produce innovations that matterWhen they reach people, the impact becomes real. Someone’s day gets easier. Some decision gets better. Some door opens.
- Real impact feeds the missionIt teaches you what the problem really is, which is almost never what you thought at the start. The loop turns again, a little faster and a little wiser.
The mission did not make that team smarter. It made them more stubborn about the right thing.
Breakthrough solutions start with reframed questions, and we are in need of breakthrough solutions in many, many realms.
Follow the friction past the screen
Here is a common pattern, described in general terms. A team sets out to make a complex financial product easier to use. The obvious move is to simplify the interface. That is the market answer, and it is not wrong. A team with a real mission, say fair access for ordinary people to something once reserved for insiders, keeps asking why it is hard in the first place. They find the problem is not the button. It is the structure behind the button: who is allowed in, how long things take to settle, what the customer has to trust. The interface fix ships in a quarter. The structural fix takes years. Only the second changes the world the customer lives in.
MIT’s Hal Gregersen has turned the better question into a team practice. In a question burst, a group spends two minutes laying out a problem, then four minutes generating only questions. He reports that over 1,500 participants have said the sessions produce useful questions at least 80 percent of the time.
Put the loop to work
- Write the change, not the productOne sentence that describes the change you want, without naming your product.
- Ask the harder questionFor your biggest customer problem, ask what would have to change for it to disappear.
- Run a question burstTwo minutes on the problem. Four minutes of questions only. Keep the ones that make the room go quiet.
- Close the loopAfter each release, write what it taught you about the real problem. Let that sharpen what you look for next.
Quick answers
What is the Impact-Innovation Loop?
A framework from Rob Frasca’s The Creator’s Journey. A clear impact mission sharpens what founders observe, visible problems produce better questions, better questions produce innovations that matter, and real impact feeds the mission.
Why do mission-driven founders innovate differently?
Rob Frasca argues that the mission changes the question. Market-driven founders ask what people will pay for. Impact-driven founders ask what would have to change for the problem to disappear, which leads them past surface fixes to structural ones.
Sources
- Rob Frasca, The Creator’s Journey (forthcoming), Chapter II, The Creator’s Mind.
- Hal Gregersen, Questions Are the Answer: A Breakthrough Approach to Your Most Vexing Problems at Work and in Life (HarperBusiness, 2018). Wording checked against the Goodreads quotation page for the book. Source
- Peter Dizikes, Q&A with Hal Gregersen on why business leaders should ask questions, MIT News, December 18, 2018. Source for the question burst method and participant results. Source