“Follow Your Passion” Is the Wrong Advice.
Passion is rarely found fully formed. It is built through commitment to a problem, one piece of work at a time.
The Creator's Journey · Chapter I, The Creator's Calling
The word “passion” is one of the most overused words in business. Every accelerator application asks for it. Every investor says they look for it. Every commencement speaker tells you to follow it. As it is usually given, the advice is wrong.
It assumes passion is something you already have, fully formed, waiting to be discovered like a buried coin. It assumes that if you find the right thing, the work will feel good. And it assumes that when the work stops feeling good, you chose wrong. None of that matches what I have seen in more than thirty years of building companies and backing founders.
Passion is built, not found
There is a second myth inside the first. It says passion is a personality trait. Passion grows through engagement with a problem over time. The more you learn about a domain, the more you see what is broken in it. The more you see what is broken, the more you care.
Commitment creates passion at least as often as passion creates commitment.
You can’t connect the dots looking forward; you can only connect them looking backward.
People quote the line from that Stanford speech about finding what you love. They skip the rest, which is mostly about dots you can only connect in hindsight. The love came from the work at least as much as the work came from the love. My own calling looked like that. On the flight deck I did not have a passion for financial software. I had a restless curiosity about information and decisions. The passion came later, inside the work, one problem at a time.
Cal Newport, a computer science professor at Georgetown, makes the same case in So Good They Can’t Ignore You. He argues that a focus on passion over skill leads to anxiety and chronic job hopping, and that people come to love their work by getting good at something valuable. He calls the alternative the craftsman mindset: ask what you can offer, not whether the work feels right yet.
The founders who last
- Strategic
- They know why the work matters, and the reason does not change when the day goes badly.
- Systematic
- Habits keep them pointed at the problem when inspiration is absent.
- Sustainable
- They do not burn hot for six months and disappear.
- Purpose-driven
- The product is the current best answer to the problem, not the point.
There is also the plainest fact of the job. You are always selling. A founder who waits to feel passionate before the next pitch will wait a long time. Commitment gets you into the next room.
Start by paying attention
- Name a problem, not a feelingWrite one sentence about a problem you would work on for a decade. Do not name a product.
- Get closer to itSpend time with the people who have it. Write down what is broken.
- Build one skill it needsPick the skill that would make you most useful to those people and practice it on purpose.
- Check commitment, not moodAfter a month, ask whether you care more about the problem than you did. That is passion forming.
Quick answers
Is “follow your passion” good advice?
Rob Frasca argues it is wrong as it is usually given. Passion is rarely found fully formed. It is built through engagement with a problem, and commitment creates passion at least as often as passion creates commitment.
How do you find your passion if you do not feel one?
Rob Frasca says you do not have to wait to feel called. You can start by paying attention to a problem, getting closer to it and building skill. Cal Newport’s So Good They Can’t Ignore You reaches a similar conclusion.
Sources
- Rob Frasca, The Creator’s Journey (forthcoming), Chapter I, The Creator’s Calling.
- Steve Jobs, commencement address, Stanford University, June 12, 2005, as published by Stanford Report. Source
- Cal Newport, So Good They Can’t Ignore You: Why Skills Trump Passion in the Quest for Work You Love (Grand Central Publishing, 2012). Source